Advertisement
X

Why Insurance Should Be About Protection, Not Just Tax Savings

One of the common mistakes people make is treating insurance and investments as interchangeable. They are not. Investments help build wealth over time, while insurance provides financial support when a specified risk materialises.

A tax advantage should be the additional benefit of buying a suitable policy, not the reason for buying an unsuitable one. Photo: AI Image
Summary
  • Insurance is meant to protect your family financially when things go wrong. Saving tax can be an added benefit, but it shouldn't be the only reason to buy a policy.

  • A policy may help you save tax, but does it offer the cover you actually need? That's the question worth asking before signing up.

  • Your insurance needs change as life moves on. Marriage, children, a home loan or rising family expenses should all figure in deciding how much cover you need.

Advertisement

For many Indians, insurance buying still follows a familiar pattern. As the financial year draws to a close, people start looking for ways to reduce their tax liability. Insurance policies often find a place on that list, sometimes without much thought about whether the cover is actually needed or suited to the buyer.

According to industry experts, this approach needs to change.

“Insurance is meant to protect individuals and their families against financial uncertainty. Tax benefits may make a policy more attractive, but they should not be the main reason for buying it,” says Ram Patrudu, Co-Founder, Trovity InsureTech.

A good financial plan starts with a simple question: What does a person need to protect? The answer will vary depending on age, income, family responsibilities, outstanding loans, health requirements and future financial commitments. A young professional with no dependants will have different insurance needs from someone with a spouse, children and a home loan to repay.

Advertisement

Buying a policy merely because it offers a tax deduction does little to address these differences.

Insurance, Investments Have Different Jobs

One of the common mistakes people make is treating insurance and investments as interchangeable. They are not.

“Investments help build wealth over time, while insurance provides financial support when a specified risk materialises. Emergency savings, meanwhile, provide money that can be accessed when an unexpected expense arises,” says Patrudu.

Each has a role to play. A person may have several investment products and still remain inadequately insured. Similarly, buying multiple insurance policies does not necessarily mean that the family has sufficient financial protection.

The focus should be on whether the cover is adequate, what risks it addresses and whether the premium can be comfortably paid over the policy term.

Are Insurance Recommendations Driven By Customer Needs?

The way insurance products are sold also deserves attention. “Commissions are a legitimate part of insurance distribution and help insurers and intermediaries reach customers. However, differences in commission structures can sometimes influence which products are recommended. This can create a situation where the product being sold may not necessarily be the one the customer needs most,” adds Patrudu.

Advertisement

The concern is not about commissions themselves. It is about ensuring that commercial considerations do not take precedence over customer interests. Buyers should understand what a policy covers, where its limitations lie, what exclusions apply and how much it will cost them over the years. A recommendation is useful only when it takes the customer’s financial circumstances into account.

Insurance Needs Change With Life

Insurance planning cannot be treated as a one-time exercise. A policy purchased several years ago may no longer provide adequate protection as family responsibilities and financial commitments grow. “Marriage, the birth of a child, buying a house, taking a large loan or a change in income are all reasons to review existing cover. Healthcare needs may also change with age, making it important to reassess health insurance periodically,” says Patrudu.

The idea is not to keep adding policies every time circumstances change. It is to check whether the existing protection is still adequate and make adjustments where necessary.

Advertisement

Look Beyond The Tax Deduction

Tax benefits should be ignored. They can certainly form part of the decision. But a tax advantage should be the additional benefit of buying a suitable policy, not the reason for buying an unsuitable one. Before signing up, buyers should ask themselves a few basic questions. What financial risk will this policy cover? Is the sum assured adequate? Can the premium be sustained over the long term? Does the policy duplicate cover that is already available?

These questions may take a little more time than simply choosing a product for its tax benefits, but they can help avoid costly mistakes.

The larger shift needed is in how households look at insurance. It should not be an annual purchase made in a hurry to save tax. It should be part of a financial plan that brings together protection, savings and investments. After all, the real value of insurance lies not in the tax deduction it offers today, but in the financial security it can provide when a family needs it most.

Advertisement
Show comments
Published At: