Advertisement
X

Delhi Consumer Panel Orders Insurer To Pay Rs 3.87 Lakh Claim After Corrected Kidney Disease Entry

A Delhi consumer commission has ordered a health insurance company to reimburse a 76-year-old woman Rs 3.87 lakh after it rejected her claim over a kidney disease entry which was corrected during admission

Delhi Consumer Commission & Health Insurance Claim Rejection Photo: AI
Summary
  • Delhi consumer commission ordered insurer to reimburse Rs 3.87 lakh hospital bill

  • Insurer rejected elderly woman's claim despite corrected hospital records and medical clarification

  • Commission found repeated document requests unjustified and claim handling deficient

  • Insurer must pay six per cent interest, Rs 50,000 compensation and Rs 35,000 litigation costs

Advertisement

The Delhi consumer commission has directed an insurance company to reimburse Rs 3,87,391, with interest, compensation and litigation costs to a 76-year-old woman who had to pay her hospital bill herself even though she held health insurance policies with a combined cover of Rs 35 lakh.

The dispute emerged following an emergency assessment in December 2023 which mentioned chronic kidney disease (CKD). The hospital corrected the entry in her records during the same admission. The insurer still sought further confirmation and later rejected her reimbursement claim, citing missing documents.

Hospital Record Corrected Before Discharge

The woman held two policies: one with a sum insured of Rs 10 lakh, for which she paid a premium of Rs 96,673, and another with a Rs 25 lakh cover and an additional premium of Rs 54,499.

She said she had disclosed her diabetes, lipid disorders and hypertension when she bought the policies. The insurer had also arranged a medical examination before issuing them. According to her, the report did not record any pre-existing heart or kidney disease.

Advertisement

During her hospital stay, a cashless claim request was sent to the insurer. It asked for medical records, investigation reports, and other clarifications. The woman said she submitted the requested information, including a certificate from her treating doctor stating that she had no history of CKD or coronary artery disease. The cashless request was not approved because the insurer said the required documents were insufficient or had not been submitted, according to a report by The Times of India.

After paying the bill, the woman filed a reimbursement claim. In January 2024, the insurer confirmed it had received her claim and asked her to send the original documents. In February, it confirmed receiving the physical papers and said the claim was being verified with the hospital.

Toward the end of March, the insurer asked for an affidavit from the treating doctor confirming that the woman had no history of CKD. She said this was unnecessary because the hospital had already corrected the entry and her doctor had provided a clarification. Her complaint said the emergency doctor would not provide a separate affidavit, as the error had been corrected in the medical record. The insurer turned down her reimbursement claim in April 2024, saying she had not provided the required documents.

Advertisement

Insurer Had Not Shown What Information Was Missing

The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-VIII (Central), Delhi, reviewed the medical records and the correspondence. It noted that the CKD entry had been corrected during the hospital stay, before the claim was raised, and that the insurer had received the treating doctor’s clarification.

The commission said an insurer can ask for documents to assess a claim, but repeated requests for information already supplied, or for documents that could not reasonably be obtained, were not justified. It also found that the insurer had not explained what essential information remained unavailable after receiving the corrected record and medical clarification.

The insurer did not file its written response within the statutory period. The commission had closed its right to submit the response and evidence in May 2025. It later considered the insurer’s written arguments only on questions of law.

The commission said the insurer had not handled the claim fairly or diligently. It held this to be a deficiency in service in its September 24, 2026, order. It directed the insurer to pay Rs 3,87,391, with six per cent annual interest from April 25, 2024, until payment. It also awarded Rs 50,000 for mental agony, harassment and inconvenience, and Rs 35,000 towards litigation expenses.

Advertisement

The commission gave the insurer 45 days to comply with the order from the date of receipt. If it fails to pay within that time, the reimbursement amount will carry nine per cent annual interest, calculated from April 25, 2024, until paid.

FAQs

How much did the Delhi consumer commission order the insurer to pay?
It ordered reimbursement of Rs 3,87,391, with 6 per cent annual interest, Rs 50,000 compensation and Rs 35,000 in litigation expenses.

Why did the insurer reject the woman’s claim?
It cited missing required documents, including an affidavit about her kidney disease history, despite the hospital having corrected the CKD entry during her admission.

What happens if the insurer does not comply within 45 days?
The reimbursement amount will carry 9 per cent annual interest from April 25, 2024, until it is paid.

Show comments
Published At: