Advertisement
X

Thane Homebuyer Gets Relief From Rs 14.25 Lakh Tax Addition Over Alleged Cash Payment

A Mumbai tribunal deleted a tax addition against a Thane flat buyer, finding that the department had not produced the emails or other evidence linking him to alleged cash payments

ITAT Mumbai Deleted A Rs 14.25 Lakh Tax Addition Against A Thane Flat Buyer Photo: AI
Summary
  • Mumbai ITAT deleted Rs 14.25 lakh unexplained cash addition against Thane homebuyer

  • Income Tax Department alleged Rs 28.5 lakh cash payment beyond registered property price

  • Tribunal found insufficient evidence and denial of cross-examination of developer’s officials

  • Registered agreements, payment records and builder confirmations can help taxpayers contest additions

Advertisement

A Thane man has won relief from a Rs 14.25 lakh addition to his taxable income after the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Mumbai, found that the department had not established that he paid cash over and above the recorded price of his flat.

The case concerned a property purchased jointly with his wife for Rs 72 lakh. The Income Tax Department alleged that the buyer had paid an additional Rs 28.5 lakh in cash to the developer. Since he held a 50 per cent share in the flat, the assessing officer treated Rs 14.25 lakh as unexplained money and added it to his income.

The tribunal deleted the addition, citing gaps in the evidence relied on by the tax authorities and the buyer’s challenge to statements made by the developer’s officials.

Department Relied On Emails And Statements

The flat was registered in April 2012. The buyer had filed his return for assessment year 2012-13, declaring income of Rs 2,71,280. The return was initially accepted, but the department later reopened the assessment after receiving information about alleged cash payments to the developer.

Advertisement

The assessing officer (AO) referred to material said to have been found in the developer group’s Gmail and Yahoo accounts, as well as an Excel sheet that reportedly listed cash payments against flats and shops. Statements from the group’s sales head and a promoter were also cited to support the allegation that the buyer had paid “on-money,” according to a recent report by The Times of India.

The buyer disputed the claim. He maintained that he and his wife had paid the declared consideration of Rs 72 lakh, as recorded in the registered agreement. He also submitted a confirmation from the builder acknowledging receipt of that amount.

He argued that the department had not shared the material said to establish the additional payment. He also objected to the use of statements from the developer’s officials without being allowed to cross-examine them. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the addition and rejected his request for cross-examination, leading him to appeal to the tribunal.

Advertisement

Tribunal Says Evidence Was Not Put On Record

The Mumbai ITAT noted that the alleged emails and other incriminating material had not been produced during the assessment proceedings or supplied to the taxpayer. The tribunal also observed that the lower authorities had not considered the builder’s confirmation acknowledging receipt of Rs 72 lakh.

It held that statements made by third parties could not, by themselves, be treated as evidence against the buyer unless they were tested through cross-examination. The department had not provided the buyer an opportunity to question the developer’s officials whose statements were relied upon.

The tribunal also considered earlier ITAT decisions concerning similar additions against buyers of properties linked to the same real estate group. Those additions had been deleted where statements were not backed by adequate supporting evidence.

On the facts of this case, the tribunal concluded that the assessing officer had not substantiated the alleged cash payment with material that could be examined. It therefore deleted the Rs 14.25 lakh addition.

Advertisement

The ruling turned on the evidence available in this case. For homebuyers responding to a tax query, agreements, payment records and confirmations can help establish the amount paid. The order also shows that an allegation based on third-party statements or electronic records must be supported by material placed on record and a fair opportunity for the taxpayer to respond.

FAQs

Why did the tax department add Rs 14.25 lakh to the buyer’s income?
It alleged that he had paid Rs 28.5 lakh in cash over the recorded flat price. His 50 per cent share was treated as unexplained money.

Why did the ITAT delete the addition?
The tribunal found that the alleged emails and other material were not put on record or shared with the buyer, and he was not allowed to cross-examine the officials whose statements were used.

What documents can help a homebuyer respond to a tax query?
Keep the registered agreement, payment records, and written confirmation from the builder showing the amount paid.

Advertisement
Show comments
Published At: