Advertisement
X

Supreme Court Restores Pension Rights Of Temporary Workers In UP, Strikes Down Two Laws

The Supreme Court struck down two Uttar Pradesh government laws relating to pension exclusion, declaring them unconstitutional. It restored the pension rights of workers who had started as temporary employees and were later regularised

SC restores UP temporary workers' pension rights
Summary
  • The Supreme Court strikes down two UP laws that exclude workers from pensionary benefits.

  • Early temporary service counts for pension calculation for regularised employees.

  • The Court held that claims must be decided within six months of the date of receipt.

Advertisement

The Supreme Court of India has struck down two state laws related to pension benefits for temporary employees who are regularised later under an official scheme. In the judgment passed on November 18, a bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma declared both laws, which blocked regularised government staff from counting their early service for pension calculation with retrospective effect, unconstitutional.

This ruling protects government employees who started their service as temporary, daily-wage, or muster-roll workers and were regularised later under an official scheme. Justice Datta stated that regularisation integrates an employee into the regular establishment, and thus, the legal relevance of their initial appointment stops. The court emphasised that the state cannot revive an employee’s original ‘temporary’ job status through retrospective laws to deny pensionary benefits.

The court invalidated both the Uttar Pradesh Qualifying Service for Pension and Validation Act, 2021, and the Uttar Pradesh Entitlement to Pension and Validation Act, 2025, using its power of judicial review.

Advertisement

The decision will benefit the eligible retired staff in state departments, including Public Works, Irrigation, and Ground Water. Many of these workers who joined as daily wagers and gave long years of service before their regularisation saw that their early working years were not counted while calculating their pension eligibility. The court ruled that the state laws violated Article 14 of the Constitution by creating such discriminatory classification. It held that it cannot be justified by the government by introducing new statutory definitions to validate denial orders of the past.

The legal battle started with the Supreme Court’s judgment dated September 2, 2019, in Prem Singh Vs State of Uttar Pradesh, in which the apex Court directed that work-charged service be counted for calculating qualifying service for pension. Following that verdict, the Uttar Pradesh government issued an ordinance in 2020 and enacted the Validation Act in 2021 to change the pension rules with retrospective effect. In 2025, the state issued another ordinance followed by the Entitlement to Pension and Validation Act, 2025, and introduced the concept of a ‘substantive appointee’ to determine an employee’s pension eligibility.

Advertisement

Employees and staff associations challenged these laws, saying that the government tried to avoid its liability under the 2019 ruling. The bench held that while lawmakers can pass retrospective legislation, they cannot override a court’s judgment without removing the legal defect identified by the court.

Taking into account the precedent, the Court ordered state authorities to check all pending pension claims again. Retired workers can now make a claim to the competent authorities, providing them with their complete service details. The authorities must decide each claim within six months of its receipt. In case of rejecting a claim, the employee must be given a hearing and the rejection must be supported by a reasoned order. The authorities must also provide the employees with a detailed breakdown of all released amounts and payment heads.  

Show comments
Published At: