The legal battle started with the Supreme Court’s judgment dated September 2, 2019, in Prem Singh Vs State of Uttar Pradesh, in which the apex Court directed that work-charged service be counted for calculating qualifying service for pension. Following that verdict, the Uttar Pradesh government issued an ordinance in 2020 and enacted the Validation Act in 2021 to change the pension rules with retrospective effect. In 2025, the state issued another ordinance followed by the Entitlement to Pension and Validation Act, 2025, and introduced the concept of a ‘substantive appointee’ to determine an employee’s pension eligibility.