As urban rental markets expand and disputes between landlords and tenants increase, understanding the exact nature of tenancy agreements has become essential. But for most tenants and landlords alike, the lines between rent agreements, lease deeds, and leave-and-license contracts remain blurry despite each falling under distinct legal regimes.
In India, different types of tenancy agreements are governed by different statutes. Rent agreements are often covered by the Rent Control Act, lease agreements fall under Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, of 1882, while the Indian Easements Act, of 1882 controls Leave and License agreements. The legal distinctions are not just academic they define rights, obligations, and the ability to seek recourse if the relationship goes sour.
Advertisement
The Rent Agreement: Short-Term, Common, but Often Misunderstood
A rent agreement is the most frequently used rental contract in residential settings. Typically drafted for 11 months, these agreements often fly under the radar of mandatory registration, helping both parties avoid higher stamp duty and registration costs.
While convenient, the 11-month format isn't just a tradition; it's strategic. By keeping the tenure below a year, landlords avoid legal complications tied to long-term leases under the Rent Control Act. But this flexibility comes with a trade-off for tenants: potential rent increases with every renewal.
Lease Agreements: Longer Tenure, Higher Security, but Less Flexibility
Unlike rent agreements, lease agreements are typically executed for longer durations, often stretching over two or more years and are most common in commercial real estate. These agreements transfer a limited interest in the property to the lessee, giving them stronger legal ground during the lease tenure.
Advertisement
Under Indian law, lease agreements are governed not only by the Transfer of Property Act but also require registration to be legally enforceable.
Still, lease agreements come with risks. If the market value of a property appreciates during the lease period, the landlord may lose out on higher potential returns due to the fixed rent clause.
Leave and License Agreements: Temporary, Revocable, and Legally Distinct
Often confused with rental agreements, leave and license agreements offer a more temporary and revocable occupancy, typically used when the owner doesn't want to grant a tenant any interest in the property.
This form of contract is not transferable or inheritable, and most importantly, it does not create a landlord-tenant relationship in the legal sense. That makes eviction, if required, far simpler.
Advertisement
These agreements are governed by the Indian Easement Act, of 1882. Unlike leases, which create interest and pass certain legal rights to the lessee, licenses merely grant permission to occupy, which can be withdrawn under agreed terms.
Understanding the Legal Distinctions: Lease vs. License
A license doesn't transfer interest; a lease does. A license is revocable; a lease isn't unless both parties consent or there's a breach. The sale of a leased property doesn't affect the lessee's rights, but a licensee could be asked to vacate upon sale.
